Water softeners, sized to your well.

Calculators and plain guides for well owners and hard-water homes: what your water test means, what size system you need and what it costs to run.

  • Penn State Extension
  • NDSU
  • WQA
  • Manufacturer manuals
Calculator

Which treatment does my water need?

gpg
ppm
Water is orange or has red particles straight from the tap
ppm
mg/L
Rotten-egg smell only from the hot tap
gpm
Considering a salt-free conditioner

Iron plus manganese

1.00ppm

Compensated hardness (5 gpg per ppm iron)
20.0 gpg
Hardness in mg/L
257 mg/L
  • Iron above 0.3 mg/L stains fixtures and laundry. That is EPA's secondary (aesthetic) standard, not a health limit.
  • A softener can take this iron: dissolved iron under 5 mg/L with hardness of 3 to 20 gpg and pH above 6.7 (Penn State). Set the iron factor from your manual.
  • If you don't want to soften, Penn State lists polyphosphate feed for iron under 2 mg/L (it keeps iron from staining but doesn't remove it) and catalytic carbon for iron under 1 mg/L.
  • This covers nuisance parameters only. For health-related contaminants, test with a certified lab and choose equipment certified to the matching NSF/ANSI standard.
How this works

Start with your numbers

Calculators with every constant sourced. No sign-up, nothing stored.

Best water softeners for well water

The best water softeners for well water, ranked by the iron, hardness, pH and flow limits in their manuals, plus the limits each maker leaves out.

See the full ranking
  1. Best overall for most wells
    Whirlpool WHES40/WHES44 cabinet water softener, front view

    Whirlpool WHES40E

    Most private wells with moderate hardness and clear-water iron up to 10 ppm

    Resin
    1.14 ft³
    Rated flow
    8.5 gpm
    Max clear-water iron
    10 ppm
    See where to buy (opens Whirlpool site)Opens whirlpoolwatersolutions.com
  2. Best for larger homes
    US Water Systems Matrixx softener with chrome-jacketed resin tank and brine tank

    US Water Systems Matrixx

    Larger homes that need 15 to 20 gpm of service flow

  3. Best upflow metered system
    SoftPro Elite water softener resin tank and brine tank

    SoftPro Elite Smart HE (well-water version)

    Well owners who want an upflow metered system with sturdier resin

  4. Best for high flow
    SpringWell SS salt-based softener with brine tank

    SpringWell SS salt-based softener

    Homes with many bathrooms that need high flow

Guides

Plain answers, with the study or manual behind each claim.

How we rank without pretending we tested.

0
hands-on testing claims. We say plainly what we did and didn't do.
72
sources linked across our guides: manuals, studies and extension services.
18
guides, each with its method on the page. How we work